The idea of neo-Psychoanalytic theory was the function of the unconscious mind (Cervone & Pervin,2019). This theory was proposed by Sigmund Freud who believed that our unconscious, subconscious, and conscious mind give way to a certain behavior (Cervone & Pervin, 2019). Emotions like fear, violence, immoral needs, selfishness lives in unconscious part of the brain and in certain situations come out as denial, dreams, speech by mistake and manners (Cervone & Pervin, 2019).
The idea of Behavioral Theory: Behavioral theory explains that the human behavior is a result of his experiences with the environment he lives in and his reaction to the external stimuli (Cervone & Pervin, 2019). Its emphasis is effect of behavior on mind (Cervone & Pervin ,2019). According to (Phelps, 2015) Behavioral theorists do not infer internal structures to account for behavior but look instead to the past or present environment to explain behavior. Behavior is studied only for what it reveals about non-observable, inferred constructs, said to be inside the person (Phelps,2015). The presence of any such non-observable structures is only inferred from behavior, never observed independent of behavior (Phelps,2015).
The concept of behavioural theory is as follows: Behavioral theory states that human conduct is a product of his interactions with the environment in which he lives as well as his responses to external stimuli (Cervone & Pervin, 2019). Its primary focus is on the impact of behaviour on the mind (Cervone & Pervin ,2019). According to (Phelps, 2015), behavioural theorists do not infer internal structures in order to account for behaviour, but rather look to the past or current environment in order to explain behavioural patterns. Behavior is only researched for what it reveals about non-observable, inferred constructs that are believed to exist within the individual (Phelps,2015). Only conduct can infer the presence of such non-observable structures, and they are never noticed on their own without the Helpance of behaviour (Phelps,2015).
There is a distinction between the two hypotheses.
The importance of the conscious, unconscious, and subconscious mind, as well as how it results in behaviour, is stressed by psychoanalytic theory, whereas behavioural theory asserts that external stimuli influence a person’s behaviour, which in turn influences the human mind, is stressed by behavioural theory. Behaviorists are therefore less interested in investigating the mental image of unconscious mind, whereas neo psychoanalysis is more interested in examining the human mind.
Difference between both theories
The psychoanalytic theory stresses upon significance of conscious, unconscious, and subconscious mind and how it results in the behavior while behavioral theory states that external stimuli affect the behavior of person which in turn affects human mind. So, behaviorists are least interested in studying the mental image of unconscious mind while neo psychoanalysis supports studying human mind.
Similarities Between these 2 theories
The similarly between the two theories is that both the theories study human behavior as their goal. One studying human thoughts while the other studying external stimuli, but the result is the same. i.e., human behavior. I feel, behavioral theory is more applicable as per my viewpoint since our actions and responses to the environment only decides our behavior.
References
Cervone, D., & Pervin, L. A. (2019). Personality: Theory and research (14th ed.). Wiley.
Phelps, B. (2015). Behavioral Perspectives on Personality and Self. Psychological Record, 65(3), 557–565. https://doi-org.ezp.waldenulibrary.org/10.1007/s40732-014-0115-y
