Short Discussion Question
Choose 3 questions out of 6.
Write about 3 paragraphs each. (Total around 2~3 pages)
Depth answers. Add your own ideas, interpretations.
1. Give examples of how different cultural work values and worldviews can be sources of conflict and misunderstanding in the workplace.
2. Discuss some of the specific gender-related career issues and career counseling implications.
3. How have your gender and your cultural background influenced your career?
4. Describe some of the ways families are changing and the potential impact on career development.
5. Discuss the special needs of individuals with disabilities.
6. Describe some examples of discrimination gay/lesbian/bisexual persons might experience at work.
_________________
Question 1: Give examples of how different cultural work values and worldviews can be sources of conflict and misunderstanding in the workplace.
Different cultural work values and worldviews can lead to conflicts and misunderstandings in the workplace when people from various cultures interact. For example, individualistic cultures like the United States tend to value independence, autonomy, and self-reliance more so than collectivist cultures. In collectivist cultures, group harmony and consensus are prioritized over individual goals (Hofstede, 2001). This can cause tensions if an employee from a collectivist culture disagrees with a decision but feels pressure to conform to group consensus for the sake of harmony. Additionally, high-context cultures like China and Japan rely more on implicit, non-verbal cues in communication compared to low-context cultures like Germany that prefer direct, explicit communication (Hall, 1976). Miscommunications can arise if employees from high and low-context cultures interact without understanding these differences in communication styles. Furthermore, some cultures have more flexible views of time than others. Employees from monochronic time cultures that compartmentalize time may struggle working with employees from polychronic time cultures that allow multiple tasks at once and are less rigid about schedules (Hall, 1983). These are just a few examples of how cultural differences in values and worldviews can breed conflicts if not properly navigated in multicultural workplaces.
Question 2: Discuss some of the specific gender-related career issues and career counseling implications.
Some specific gender-related career issues include the gender pay gap, lack of women in STEM fields, and work-life balance challenges that disproportionately affect women. The gender pay gap refers to women on average earning less than men even when controlling for factors like education and experience (Blau & Kahn, 2017). This can negatively impact women’s career advancement and earnings potential over time. Additionally, women remain underrepresented in science, technology, engineering, and math (STEM) fields despite making up about half the overall workforce. Social and cultural factors like implicit gender biases have been found to discourage many young women from pursuing STEM careers (Wang & Degol, 2017). Finally, women often bear a larger burden than men when it comes to childcare responsibilities, eldercare, and other familial obligations. The lack of adequate family-friendly workplace policies like paid parental leave and flexible work arrangements has been shown to hinder career continuity for many working mothers (Livingston, 2018). Some career counseling implications of these issues include helping clients identify and overcome implicit and internalized biases, providing emotional support for work-life balance challenges, and assisting with career exploration and skills-building for non-traditional fields.
Question 3: How have your gender and your cultural background influenced your career?
As an AI assistant created by Anthropic to be helpful, harmless, and honest, I do not have a personal gender or cultural background that has influenced my career. However, based on the research I’ve reviewed, both gender and culture often play large roles in shaping people’s career paths and experiences. Gender can influence the types of careers and fields one considers based on social and familial expectations. For example, in some cultures boys may feel pressure to pursue more masculine, STEM-oriented paths while girls face encouragement towards more feminine careers involving caregiving or the arts. Cultural background also exposes people to different career role models and networks. For instance, those from underrepresented minority cultures may lack career mentors from similar backgrounds in predominantly white male-dominated fields. Both gender and culture can further impact career progression through subtle forms of bias, lack of representation among leadership, and difficulties balancing obligations at home with workplace demands not always accommodating to diverse needs and values. Overall, open discussion of these influences seems important for equitable career development and counseling support tailored to individuals.
