Golaki et al. BMC Medical Schooling (2022) 22:112 https://doi.org/10.1186/s12909-Zero22-03144-w
R E S E A R C H
The impact of Flipped Classroom by Close to Peer Schooling (FC by NPE) on affected person security data retention in nursing and midwifery college students: a solomon four-group design Sima Poormahdi Golaki1, Farahnaz Kamali2, Razieh Bagherzadeh2, Fatemeh Hajinejad3 and Hakimeh Vahedparast3*
Summary Introduction: Choosing an applicable educating methodology is without doubt one of the key levels in schooling. This examine is an try and delve into the impact of FC by NPE on affected person security data retention in nursing and midwifery college students.
Strategies: A randomized managed trial, utilizing the Solomon design, was carried out in 2019 on 82 nursing and midwifery college students enrolled from Bushehr nursing and midwifery college. The Topics had been then allotted to 4 teams through block randomization. The Topics in each intervention teams studied the tutorial content material on-line for two weeks and subsequently attended the FC by NPE. Each management teams merely acquired schooling primarily based on standard methodology. The post-test was as soon as administered to the 4 examine teams instantly after finishing this system and as soon as once more 2 months after it.
Outcomes: The posttest imply scores of information retention in each intervention teams remained the identical (P = Zero.1), whereas they had been larger within the management teams (P < Zero.05). The modifications within the imply scores of the post-test within the inter- vention and follow-up teams didn’t reveal a statistically important distinction between the 4 examine teams (P = Zero.130, F = 1.941). Conclusion: The usage of the FC by NPE elevated the data imply scores; nevertheless, it didn’t have an effect on knowl- edge retention. Given the infancy of this pedagogical strategy, additional research are wanted to research its results on numerous studying outcomes.
Key phrases: Flipped Classroom, Close to-Peer Schooling, Affected person Security, Nursing, Midwifery, College students, Data Retention
© The Writer(s) 2022. Open Entry This text is licensed underneath a Artistic Commons Attribution Four.Zero Worldwide License, which allows use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and replica in any medium or format, so long as you give applicable credit score to the unique creator(s) and the supply, present a hyperlink to the Artistic Commons licence, and point out if modifications had been made. The pictures or different third get together materials on this article are included within the article’s Artistic Commons licence, except indicated in any other case in a credit score line to the fabric. If materials just isn’t included within the article’s Artistic Commons licence and your supposed use just isn’t permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will want to acquire permission immediately from the copyright holder. To view a duplicate of this licence, go to http:// creat iveco mmons. org/ licen ses/ by/Four. Zero/. The Artistic Commons Public Area Dedication waiver (http:// creat iveco mmons. org/ publi cdoma in/ zero/1. Zero/) applies to the info made obtainable on this article, except in any other case acknowledged in a credit score line to the info.
Background Improvements and speedy modifications in socioeconomic, politi- cal, and technological domains have principally challenged medical schooling with their very own complexities. They’ve moreover made the roles of medical science educators rather more distinguished and extra difficult than ever.
Open Entry
*Correspondence: h.vahedparast@bpums.ac.ir three Division of Nursing, Nursing and Midwifery College, Bushehr College of Medical Sciences, Salmanefarsi Blvd, Bushehr, Iran Full checklist of creator info is offered on the finish of the article
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/Four.Zero/
http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.Zero/
http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.Zero/
http://crossmark.crossref.org/dialog/?doi=10.1186/s12909-Zero22-03144-w&area=pdf
Web page 2 of 11Golaki et al. BMC Medical Schooling (2022) 22:112
Furthermore, it now not appears potential to steer medical stu- dents towards progress through standard strategies [1].
Within the current period, deciding on essentially the most applicable educating methodologies is without doubt one of the methods adopted by academics to enhance the standard of their schooling based on college students’ particular targets and circumstances [2]. Therefore, utilizing new educating methodologies is amongst one in every of these methods. The FC strategy is thus assumed as one of many new pedagogical fashions, which relies on know-how [3], even when such strategies have created sev- eral challenges in schooling, particularly in medical sci- ences [4–8].
Some research have additional supported the FC as a peda- gogical strategy for impartial studying [4], which leads to extra studying in contrast with different strategies [8], and may even produce excessive ranges of satisfaction in learners [7]. Nonetheless, there has additionally been proof of lack of satisfaction on the a part of the learners [8] and the identical results as different educating strategies [9]. The outcomes of a evaluate on nursing schooling indicated contradic- tory leads to relation to the impact of utilizing the FC on the degrees of satisfaction, studying price, and grade level aver- age in college students [5, 8]. Present proof additionally results in the belief pedagogical mannequin, even a brand new one alone, can’t advance studying, so an integration of sev- eral strategies must be exercised to create lively studying and considering in learners [6]. Evidently the mixing of two new pedagogical strategies can cowl the weak- nesses of one another. On this sense, the NPE, as one of many successfully constructive pedagogical strategies, is commonly evalu- ated by medical college students [10], as a result of it’s believed that friends are extra conversant in their very own academic wants and may higher perceive these of different college students and Help them be taught [11].
Affected person security (PS), as one of many priorities of worldwide well being, is a crucial subject in medical schooling that requires using long-lasting strategies of educating. Accordingly, utilization of pedagogical methods is a key factor in enhancing attitudes and practices related to PS. The NPE has been thus acknowledged formally and informally by many organizations as an efficient means to supply PS schooling [3, 12]. Though most research haven’t up to now assessed data retention [13–16], their outcomes present that this kind of schooling can show efficient in PS [14], by enhancing attitudes towards PS in college students [16], thus enhancing their probabilities of success in medical teaching programs [17].
Sadly, many research on medical college students have demonstrated that they obtain inadequate schooling to extend Help capabilities to make sure PS and have even gone up to now to say that they lack the required knowl- edge or expertise [1]. For the reason that world of schooling in the present day has shifted its focus from educating to studying [17], medical
science schooling together with nursing and midwifery requires basic modifications [18]. A evaluate of the lit- erature reveals that new strategies of educating usually are not totally fascinating and customary, both [19]. For this rea- son, schooling specialists search to use completely different teach- ing methodologies concurrently [20] to take away their limitations and downsides. Due to this fact, contemplating the significance of information retention in PS schooling for nursing and midwifery college students and the irreparable hurt brought on by college students’ inadequate data of PS, an integration of two new strategies of educating to cowl the weaknesses of one another appears of utmost impor- tance. The current examine was undertaken as an try to check the impact of FC by NPE and traditional strategies on PS data retention in nursing and mid- wifery college students enrolled in Bushehr College of Medi- cal Sciences, Bushehr, Iran.
Strategies Research design This examine was a randomized managed trial (IRCT code: IRCT20090522001930N3, 18/three/2019) with a pre- test-posttest and follow-up in addition to intervention and management teams. The Solomon four-group design was utilized to take away the consequences of the pretest in sensitiz- ing the scholars and stopping injury to the exterior validity of the examine. On this sense, the samples had been ran- domly divided into 4 teams, i.e., two intervention teams and two management teams. Then, solely the pretest was administered to 1 intervention group and one con- trol group, after which all 4 teams acquired a post-test/ follow-up data retention check.
Topics The nursing and midwifery college students of their third- semester had been enrolled within the examine and had been divided into 4 teams. As the overall variety of the scholars within the lecture rooms was 92, 23 topics had been consid- ered for every group, of whom 46 had been uncovered to the traditional methodology and 46 had been uncovered to the FC by NPE setting. The topics had been then divided into 4 teams through block randomization. First, the teams had been decided, with A and B representing the intervention teams 1 and a couple of, and C and D repre- senting the management teams 1 and a couple of, respectively. Then, blocking was carried out utilizing the random allocation software program. To have an equal proportion of the nurs- ing and midwifery college students in every group, they had been blocked individually. Since there have been 64 nursing and 28 midwifery college students, eight Eight-part blocks and 7 Four-part blocks had been thought-about, respectively. College students had been assigned to the blocks primarily based on the attendance checklist that was obtained from the college’s schooling
Web page three of 11Golaki et al. BMC Medical Schooling (2022) 22:112
division. Block randomization was carried out by one of many researchers (R.B.), who was unaware of the allocation of the scholars to intervention and management teams. Not one of the college students knew to which group they belonged earlier than this system started.
The inclusion standards on this examine included stu- dents enrolled within the third semester of nursing and midwifery program, accessing a pc or smartphone, and willingness to take part within the analysis. Then again, the exclusion standards had been absenteeism for any motive, not viewing the tutorial content material, and unwillingness to proceed with the examine.
Typical methodology The management group was taught within the context of a workshop. The workshop group consisted of three two-hour classes held in 1 day. PPTs had been used to clarify the educating contents. The lecturing methodology was the predominant strategy used within the work- store, adopted by a question-and-answer interval and group work . The educating contents for the management teams had been the identical as for the intervention teams. Fig. 1 illustrates a abstract of the examine within the type of a flowchart.
FC by NPE methodology The trainer ready the content material earlier than the category. The PPTs and the Camtasia Studio software program had been additionally employed to organize the tutorial content material and to current it to the intervention teams. The content material was then uploaded to an internet site particularly designed for this objective 2 weeks earlier than the implementation of the FC by NPE, and the members of the intervention teams had been requested to review the total course content material inside 2 weeks earlier than the category started. After shopping the web- website, the customers had been greeted with a welcome message that requested them to create their private info web page by typing of their usernames and passwords. As a result of interactive design of the web site, the scholars in each intervention teams may entry it as customers at any time and place by connecting to the Web with their smart- telephones, tablets, and private computer systems and look at the tutorial content material uploaded on the web site.
The researchers may rapidly examine the most recent follow- up standing of the course accomplished by the scholars within the intervention teams from the administration panel. As well as, additional follow-ups had been completed, when mandatory, to encourage the scholars to review the tutorial con- tent by sending messages or making telephone calls.
The close to peer (as a grasp’s scholar in nursing) additionally acquired the required coaching in three two-hour
Fig. 1 A abstract of the examine within the type of a flowchart
Web page Four of 11Golaki et al. BMC Medical Schooling (2022) 22:112
classes earlier than implementing the FC underneath the supervi- sion of the related educator. To keep away from any errors in con- veying the tutorial ideas, the close to peer may lead the classroom within the presence of the educator. The edu- cational content material was then introduced within the type of three two-hour classes throughout 1 day. The close to peer divided the scholars into teams of 5 – 6, and the scholars had been then requested to take a seat subsequent to one another with their counterparts in the identical group. The close to peer briefly defined the lesson plan and the educational aims on the onset of the category and summarized the primary con- cepts of the lesson on the finish. The usual medical sce- narios associated to the ideas had been drawn from a ebook revealed by the Ministry of Well being and Medical Educa- tion, entitled as Affected person Security [21], previous to the interven- tion, and had been then introduced within the classroom. Subsequent, the learners got 5 min to research every situation with all their group members and reply the questions cor- responding to every situation. Afterwards, every group was requested to talk about the situation and reply the ques- tions, focus on them with the close to peer and different college students throughout the classroom, and analyze and reply the ques- tions associated to the medical situations, to change into conversant in the applying of theoretical data in medical apply.
Intervention Upon explaining the analysis process and receiv- ing the knowledgeable consent type, the pre-test was admin- istered to the intervention group one and the management group one. The management group acquired the PS program coaching through the traditional methodology, whereas the interven- tional group engaged within the FC by NPE strategy. Typical educating (for the management teams) was completed first and the FC by NPE educating was completed later to attenuate the direct impact of flipped educating methodology on the management group. After the category was over, all the scholars within the 4 teams had been examined, and a couple of months after this system, all of the 4 teams acquired a posttest to evaluate their data retention. The topics had been administered the identical check, which was designed by the researchers to judge the degrees of information in all of the three levels, i.e., earlier than, instantly after, and a couple of months after the intervention. It must be talked about that solely identification numbers had been used as a substitute of actual names within the assessments. It was emphasised that check scores had no impact on grades or efficiency within the class. All the scholars had been unaware of their assignments and situations earlier than this system. To judge the educational outcomes, the check was carried out by one of many examination committee mem- bers, who was on the analysis staff. Fig. 1 is a flowchart that summarizes the FC by NPE and the conven- tional methodology.
The content material of the PS schooling program was additionally pre- pared primarily based on the usual rules of PS supplied by the World Well being Group (WHO) [22], scientific references [23, 24], in addition to circulars of Iran’s Ministry of Well being and Medical Schooling [21]. The academic content material included details about the essential ideas of affected person security, forms of medical errors, threat administration, qualities of efficient staff gamers, affected person security activi- ties, in addition to 9 affected person security options. All of the sub- jects acquired the identical content material, the identical syllabus, and the identical sensible steering. Desk 1 illustrates the con- tent of the PS schooling program and a abstract of the associated particulars.
Knowledge analysis A demographic type and the Affected person Security Knowl- edge Retention Examination (PSKRE) had been used to gather the analysis information.
The demographic type included gadgets on age, gender, yr of admission, being native, place of residence (i.e., dormitory or personal residence), and discipline of examine.
In an effort to develop the PSKRE, 70 questions had been ini- tially ready and designed primarily based on blueprints and schooling aims related to PS set by the Minis- strive of Well being and Medical Schooling. Then, the questions had been submitted to 10 college members of the College of Nursing and two consultants within the discipline of PS to evaluate the validity. Afterwards, the questions had been reviewed by stated college members and their opinions had been utilized within the last draft. Lastly, the questions had been decreased to incorporate 32 four-option multiple-choice questions that lined all of the features of information related to PS.
Statements All protocols had been carried out in accordance with rel- evant tips and laws. All interventional pro- tocols, particularly, Flipped Classroom by Close to Peer Schooling (and related protocols) had been authorized by the Ethics Committee of Bushehr College of Medical Sciences (Code: 1397.128.IR.BPUMS.REC) and Iranian Registry of Medical Trials (IRCT20090522001930N3) in 18/three/2019. Knowledgeable consent was obtained from all sub- jects, and all strategies had been carried out in accordance with the related tips and laws.
Knowledge Assessment The statistical analyzer (RB) didn’t know the iden- tity of any of the topics, as numbers had been used as a substitute of their actual names and the letters of the alphabet had been used as identifiers for the teams. To explain the info, descriptive statistics together with frequency, imply, and SD had been used. The Shapiro- Wilk check was additionally employed to look at the info
Web page 5 of 11Golaki et al. BMC Medical Schooling (2022) 22:112
distribution. Furthermore, the Kruskal-Wallis check, the Chi-square check, and the Fisher’s actual check had been uti- lized to check the demographic variables between the 4 teams. Moreover, the paired-samples t-test or the repeated measures Assessment of variance (ANOVA) was employed to check the imply scores
within the dependent teams. The independent-samples t-test and the one-way ANOVA had been additionally used for between-group comparisons. The SPSS Statistics software program (model 19) was employed to conduct statis- tical assessments, and the importance stage was thought-about lower than Zero.05 with all of the circumstances.
Desk 1 The content material of the affected person security schooling program
Matter Element Contents
Primary Ideas of Affected person Security Introduction of affected person security and legal guidelines
Introduction of medical establishment certification mark
Significance of affected person security
Definitions & incidence of medical errors
Forms of Medical Errors Treatment occasions
Healthcare-associated infections
Surgical errors
Laboratory errors
Documentation
Affected person Falls
Strain ulcer
Danger Administration Determine the chance
Danger Assessment (Quantify & Prioritize Danger)
Methods to scale back, remove or switch threat
Steady monitoring
Efficient communication
Being an Efficient Workforce Participant Workforce & Values, roles and duties
Studying kinds
Listening expertise
Workforce coordination
Efficient management
Traits of profitable groups
Efficient communication and communication instruments
Battle decision
Analysis of staff efficiency
Affected person security actions Studying from errors to stop hurt
Being an efficient staff participant
Affected person identification
Bedsores prevention actions
Fall prevention actions
An infection prevention actions
9 Affected person Security Options Look-alike, sound-alike remedy names
Affected person identification
Communication throughout affected person handovers;
Efficiency of correct procedures at appropriate physique websites
Management of concentrated electrolyte options
Assuring remedy accuracy at transitions in care
Avoiding catheter and tubing misconnections
Single-use of injection units
Improved hand hygiene
Web page 6 of 11Golaki et al. BMC Medical Schooling (2022) 22:112
Outcomes This examine was accomplished utilizing the Solomon four-group design with two management teams, in addition to two interven- tion teams, one with and one with out a pretest, the con- trol group one and the intervention group one (with a pretest) and the management group two and the intervention group two (with out a pretest).
On this examine, a complete variety of 92 nursing and mid- wifery college students (i.e., 64 nursing college students and 28 mid- wifery college students) participated in 4 teams of 23, within the type of two intervention teams and two management teams. Out of the members within the 4 intervention and con- trol teams, 10 had been excluded from the examine as a consequence of non- participation (Fig. 1).
The members included 51 feminine college students (62.2%) and 31 male counterparts (37.Eight%) with a complete imply age of 21.23 ± 1.65 years. The imply and the SD of the age of the intervention teams one and two had been 20.73 ± Zero.86 and 21.28 ± 1.30 years, respectively. Moreover, the imply and the SD of the age of the management teams one and two had been 21.75 ± 2.75 and 21.22 ± Zero.94 years, respectively. Furthermore, the Kruskal-Wallis check outcomes didn’t present a statistically important distinction between the 4 teams by way of age (x2 = three.91; p = Zero.271). The 4 teams didn’t differ with regard to different demographic variables (Desk 2).
The distribution of the pretest scores in each the inter- vention and management teams one, in addition to within the posttest and the follow-up in all 4 teams was discovered regular.
The PS data scores earlier than the intervention within the two teams of intervention one and management one had been 15.60 ± 1.924and 16.65 ± 2.10, respectively, which weren’t considerably completely different (p = Zero.Zero98).
The outcomes of the within-group comparisons revealed that the imply rating of the PSKRE within the intervention and management teams one was completely different at 3 times. The post- hoc check outcomes additionally established that the imply scores of the posttest and the follow-up had been considerably larger than these of the pretest within the intervention group one (p-values in each circumstances had been lower than Zero.Zero01) and the imply rating of the follow-up in contrast with that of the posttest confirmed a statistically important descending pattern (p = Zero.Zero06). In Management Group One, the post-test imply rating (p < Zero.Zero01) was considerably larger than that of the pre-test, however there was no statistically important distinction between the imply scores of the pretest and the follow-up (p = Zero.100). The follow-up imply rating was considerably decrease than that of the posttest (p = Zero.Zero03). In Intervention Group Two, the PSKRE imply rating within the posttest and the follow-up was not statistically signifi- cant. Nonetheless, the PSKRE imply scores for the Management Group Two, the intervention group, and the overall management teams within the follow-up was considerably decrease than that of the posttest (Desk three).
The outcomes of the between-group comparisons con- firmed that the modifications within the imply scores from the pretest to the posttest had been completely different between the inter- vention and management teams one. The intervention group
Desk 2 Comparability of demographic variables between the 4 intervention and management teams
The check used is the chi-square or Fisher’s actual check
for age Kruskal-wallis check was completed
*worth is fisher actual
**the worth are Imply and commonplace deviation
Variable Variable ranges Intervention 1(n:23) N (%) or Imply (SD)*
Intervention 2(n:23) N (%)or Imply (SD)**
Management 1(n:23) N (%)or Imply (SD)*
Management 2(n:23) N (%)or Imply (SD)*
X2 or Fisher* P worth
Age 20.73 (Zero.86)** 21.28 (1.30)** 21.75 (2.75) ** 21.22 (Zero.94) ** three.91 Zero.271
Intercourse Lady 12 (23.5) 12 (23.5) 15 (29.Four) 12 (23.5) 2.758 Zero.430
Boy 11 (35.5) 9 (29.Zero) 5 (16.1) 6 (19.Four)
Marital standing Single 21 (27.6) 20 (26.three) 18 (23.7) 17 (22.Four) Zero.817* Zero.146
Married 2 (33.three) 1 (16.7) 2 (33.three) 2 (16.7)
residing space Metropolis 17 (23.9) 20 (28.2) 17 (23.9) 17 (23.9) Four.834* Zero.183
Village 6 (54.5) 1 (9.1) three (27.three) 1 (9.1)
Indigenous Sure 14 (28.Zero) 13 (26.Zero) 13 (26.Zero) 10 (20.Zero) Zero.366 Zero.947
No 9 (28.1) Eight (25.Zero) 7 (21.9) Eight (25.Zero)
Residence whereas finding out
Non-public home three (23.1) Four (30.Eight) Four (30.Eight) 2 (15.Four) Zero.948* Zero.855
Dormitory 20 (29.Zero) 17 (24.6) 16 (23.2) 16 (23.2)
Subject of Research Nursing 16 (26.2) 16 (26.2) 16 (26.2) 13 (21.three) Zero.692 Zero.895
Midwifery 5 (33.three) Four (23.Eight) 5 (19.Zero) 7 (23.Eight)
Web page 7 of 11Golaki et al. BMC Medical Schooling (2022) 22:112
additionally confirmed a better rating enhance. Moreover, the modifications within the PSKRE imply scores between the pretest and the follow-up had been completely different in each intervention teams one and Management Group One, i.e., rising and fall- ing developments within the imply scores within the intervention group and the management group, respectively (Desk Four).
The modifications within the PSKRE imply scores from the post- check to the follow-up weren’t statistically important between the 4 examine teams (Desk 5). As well as, the modifications within the imply and the SD from the post-test to the follow-up within the two teams of intervention and whole management had been 2.48 ± 5.15 and Four.47 ± Four.49, respectively. The 2 teams didn’t have a statistically important differ- ence by way of modifications of their imply scores (t = 1.89; p = Zero.071).
Dialogue The primary objective of this examine was to check the consequences of PS schooling utilizing the FC by NPE and the traditional strategies on data retention asso- ciated with PS in nursing and midwifery college students. The examine outcomes confirmed that the mixing of the FC and the NPE in contrast with the traditional strategies had broadened the degrees of information within the college students within the discipline of PS. Nonetheless, PS schooling by the FC by NPE was not considerably completely different from the traditional strategies, by way of their results on knowl- edge retention amongst nursing and midwifery college students, 2 months following the intervention.
The outcomes of the within-group comparisons confirmed that each FC by NPE and traditional strategies may enhance learners’ data. The between-group comparability outcomes additionally demonstrated a larger enhance in studying within the group receiving the FC by NPE and the four-group Solomon design confirmed these findings. It was established that extra studying happened within the intervention group than within the management group, even by way of the consequences of the pretest.
Restricted analysis has up to now examined the integra- tion of the FC with different strategies [3, 25, 26] and there was no analysis obtainable, to the perfect of the authors’ data, reflecting on the FC by NPE. There- fore, the examine findings had been in contrast with some investigations that had explored the NPE, in addition to the FC, independently. The examine findings had been con- sistent with these by, Shohani et al. (2020), Kim et al. (2019), Guraya et al. (2020), on NPE) [12, 27, 28], and Hu et al. (2018), Li et al. (2020), Charles-Ogan G, Wil- liams (2015) and Chu et al. (2019) on utilizing the FC [18, 29–31]. Nonetheless, these findings weren’t consistent with the examine by Hatami-Rad et al. (2017) and Sevenhuysen et al. (2014) on NPE [32, 33]. Maybe the rationale for the inconsistency of the outcomes was that, an integration of the FC and NPE was used within the current examine, lead- ing to larger effectiveness of schooling and a differ- ence between the intervention and the management teams by way of the PSKE imply scores. It’s believed that utilizing a educating methodology primarily based on an academic idea alone can’t promote studying, so an integra- tion of pedagogical strategies must be used to cre- ate lively studying considering in learners [34]. One other level was that, the degrees of information in college students had been evaluated within the current examine, whereas within the talked about investigations, medical expertise and efficiency had been appraised. The complexity and the precise difficul- ties of medical expertise [27] may very well be thus a motive for the inconsistency of the findings. Additional research may additionally decide the consequences of comparable pedagogical interven- tions on completely different ranges of information.
Then again, the current examine was not in settlement with the stories by Whillier et al. (2015) and Harrington et al. (2015) on utilizing the FC [5, 27]. On this sense, Whillier et al. (2015) discovered that ranges of satisfac- tion in college students, in addition to their imply scores by way of data within the FC and structured lecture rooms instructed by academics by problem-solving and case examine had been comparable. The explanation for the distinction
Desk three Inside group comparability of the typical rating of affected person security administration earlier than, instantly after and in addition 2 months
*Report statistics is F worth
The PSKRE imply rating within the management group two, the intervention group, and the overall management teams within the follow-up was considerably decrease than that within the posttest
Group Pre-test Put up-test Observe up t or F* P worth Imply ± SD Imply ± SD Imply ± SD
Intervention 1 15.60 ± 1.924 25.17 ± three.32 21.60 ± three.29 64.889* < Zero.Zero01 Intervention 2 – 24.40 ± three.67 23.38 ± three.89 1.Zero59 Zero.303 Management 1 16.65 ± 2.10 20.80 ± Four.16 16.10 ± three.55 11.120* < Zero.Zero01 Management 2 – 21.27 ± three.86 17.05 ± three.33 Four.880 < Zero.Zero01 Whole intervention – 24.81 ± three.47 22.33 ± three.60 three.164 Zero.Zero03 Whole management – 21.03 ± three.98 16.55 ± three.44 6.Zero01 < Zero.Zero01
Web page Eight of 11Golaki et al. BMC Medical Schooling (2022) 22:112
Ta b
le Four
C o
m p
ar is
o n
o f
m ea
n c
h an
g es
in p
at ie
n t
sa fe
ty m
an ag
em en
t sc
o re
b ef
o re
a n
d im
m ed
ia te
ly a
ft er
t h
e in
te rv
en ti
o n
a n
d a
ls o
b ef
o re
a n
d 2
m o
n th
s af
te r
th e
in te
rv en
ti o
n
b et
w ee
n c
o n
tr o
l g ro
u p
s 1
an d
in te
rv en
ti o
n 1
Te st
p er
fo rm
ed : I
n d
ep en
d en
t t
th e
PS Ok
RE m
ea n
s co
re in
t h
e co
n tr
o l g
ro u
p t
w o,
t h
e in
te rv
en ti
o n
g ro
u p
, a n
d t
h e
to ta
l c o
n tr
o l g
ro u
p s
in t
h e
fo llo
w -u
p w
as s
ig n
ifi ca
n tl
y lo
w er
t h
an t
h at
in t
h e
p o
st te
st
Ti m
e G
ro u
p (N
) M
ea n
d iff
er en
ce St
an d
ar d
d
ev ia
ti o
n M
ea n
d iff
er en
ce t
st at
is ti
c D
eg re
e o
f fr
ee d
o m
P va
lu e
A ve
ra g
e St
an d
ar d
e rr
o r
A ss
u ra
n ce
in te
rv al
fo r
m ea
n
d iff
er en
ce
Lo w
li m
it H
ig h
li m
it
Po st
-t es
t m
in u
s p
re -t
es t
In te
rv en
ti o
n 1
(2 three)
9. 57
2. 83
5. 41
1. 28
2. 77
Eight. 05
Four. 20
Four 41
< Zero
.Zero 01
C o
n tr
o l 1
(2 Zero)
Four. 15
5. 12
Fo llo
w u
p m
in u
s b
ef o
re
in te
rv en
ti o
n In
te rv
en ti
o n
1 (2
three) 6.
00 Four.
20 6.
55 1.
25 Four.
01 9.
09 5.
21 1
41 <
Zero .Zero
01
C o
n tr
o l 1
(2 Zero)
− Zero.
55 Four.
01
Web page 9 of 11Golaki et al. BMC Medical Schooling (2022) 22:112
may very well be associated to the tutorial content material. Within the pre- despatched examine, the PS program was introduced by the FC as ruled by NPE, because it was one of the necessary dimensions of high quality of care and any hurt to sufferers was in battle with the philosophy of well being care. Within the PS schooling, the outline of pure occasions and fascinating, goal, and tangible situations may trigger the content material to not be introduced in a soul- much less means. Due to this fact, learners’ consideration may very well be extra drawn to the tutorial content material, and it may change into extra understandable to them.
Whillier et al., then again, had used the FC to show neuroanatomy [35]. Though this strategy was considerably self-directed studying [36, 37], it may not be very appropriate for biomedical programs and people with heavy content material. In fact, the impact of recent pedagogical meth- ods on completely different contents wants additional investigation. The distinction between the 2 research could be additionally associated to the traditional strategies with which the brand new methodology was in contrast. Within the examine by Whillier et al. (2015), the content material was supplied for the scholars on a web-based supply earlier than educating started through the traditional meth- ods. That is whereas within the current examine, the content material was supplied for the scholars concurrently the work- store program began utilizing the traditional strategies. It is very important observe that a lot of the classes had been taught in a standard schooling context, the place this examine was carried out (Iran) and there was little use of recent strategies such because the Web to add content material and the NPE or the FC. This novelty may thus enhance the attractive- ness of the strategy and make it more practical. In gen- eral, primarily based on the examine outcomes, the mixing of the 2 new strategies of educating may make the schooling of PS matters more practical than the traditional meth- ods. The FC can also be technology-dependent, and college students plan for his or her studying primarily based on their completely different studying talents and kinds [38, 39]. This characteristic, together with the extra attractiveness of the strategy, the bolder function of stu- dents in studying, in addition to the much less stress due to the NPE may be among the many causes for the larger affect of
the built-in methodology of the FC and the NPE. Nonetheless, these outcomes can’t be generalized to educating different programs, as a result of it doesn’t imply that integrating the FC and the NPE is essentially the best strat- egy. Accordingly, it’s urged that sufficient area and amenities be supplied for using web-based schooling, in addition to the infrastructure for the apply of contemporary educating strategies together with the mixing of those strategies at universities. As well as, the required con- ditions must be placed on the agenda of universities for inspecting the impact of recent strategies to find out essentially the most applicable ones for course contents.
The examine findings confirmed that this pedagogical methodology had no impact on college students’ data retention after 2 months of schooling in contrast with the con- ventional strategies. Nonetheless, the PSKRE imply scores 2 months after the intervention had been nonetheless larger within the two intervention teams than the management group, however the drop within the imply scores from the posttest to the follow-up was comparable within the 4 examine teams. Javaheri et al. (2018) of their examine of the impact of peer schooling and Graham et al. (2019) and Gu et al. (2020) by inspecting the affect of the FC additional confirmed that the degrees of knowl- edge on the follow-up had been larger within the intervention group, a discovering which is consistent with the current examine [3, 38, 39]. These research had not measured the modifications within the imply scores from the posttest to the follow-up, which may point out a lower in data over time as a greater criterion for assessing retention. The current examine revealed that data loss after the posttest was comparable within the intervention and management teams. In reality, the upper imply rating of the PSKRE follow-up was the output of extra studying and a better data rating instantly after the intervention. Due to this fact, inspecting the decline in studying over time may result in a greater and extra specific understanding of the affect of recent strategies of educating and the built-in ones and this Help academics resolve to pick out essentially the most applicable meth- ods. Deep studying can additional stabilize the acquired data and result in educational achievement [40].
Desk 5 Comparability of imply modifications in security administration rating instantly after and a couple of months after intervention between the 4 teams
Check carried out: one-way Assessment of variance
The outcomes of the between-group comparisons confirmed that the modifications within the imply scores from the pretest to the posttest had been completely different between the intervention and management teams one
Time Group (N) Common modifications Normal deviation F P worth
Observe minus post-test Intervention 1 (23) −three.57 Four.91 1.941 Zero.130 Intervention 2 (20) −1.25 5.28 Management 1 (20) −Four.70 5.38 Management 2 (18) −Four.22 three.67
Web page 10 of 11Golaki et al. BMC Medical Schooling (2022) 22:112
Due to this fact, it is very important examine data retention throughout completely different pedagogical strategies. The purpose is that studying and data retention are a part of the problems that must be measured in trendy educating strategies after which in contrast with standard ones. As well as, college students’ satisfaction with educating strategies and their attractiveness are among the many points that must be con- sidered when utilizing completely different pedagogical strategies. In the long run, it must be famous that the imply lack of data from the posttest to the follow-up was numerically decrease within the intervention group; nevertheless, the interval vary was huge which may be because of the small pattern measurement of this examine. Repeating a examine with a bigger pattern measurement may produce extra correct outcomes.
Sadly, the current examine suffered from some limitations. For instance, it didn’t assess scholar satis- faction, so it’s urged that it’s thought-about in future research. One other limitation of this examine was the compar- ison of a brand new methodology built-in with the traditional one, which didn’t decide whether or not the built-in methodology was more practical than the 2 new strategies of the FC and the NPE alone. As with most pedagogi- cal interventions, it’s potential to change info between the management and intervention teams, which constitutes one other limitation of this examine. Motivation, expertise, and angle are related within the comparability of teams, however the current examine didn’t contemplate these con- founding variables. Due to this fact, the achieved consequence can’t be related to solely the educating methodology. Thus, it’s endorsed that these variables be taken under consideration in future research.
Conclusion The findings of the current examine confirmed that using the FC by NPE may enhance the PSKRE imply scores and thus enhance studying, however, basically, it had no impact on data retention related to PS in nurs- ing and midwifery college students. Given the restricted variety of research on this discipline, it’s endorsed that additional analysis be carried out with bigger pattern sizes in different fields and disciplines of medical sciences, and addition- ally look at college students’ ranges of satisfaction with completely different educating strategies.
Abbreviations FC: Flipped Classroom; FC by NPE: Flipped Classroom by Close to Peer Schooling; NPE: Close to Peer Schooling; PS: Affected person security; PSKRE: Affected person Security Data Retention Examination; RCT : Randomized managed trial; WHO: World Well being Group.
Acknowledgements This examine was extracted from MS thesis authorized. The authors respect the college members and college students for his or her participations. The researchers thank Dr. Homamodin Javadzade, head of the Salamooz website.
Writer particulars SPG: MS Pupil of Nursing, Pupil Analysis Committee, College of nursing and midwifery Bushehr College of Medical Sciences, Bushehr, Iran. FK: PhD of Medical Schooling, Nursing and Midwifery College. Bushehr College of Medical Sciences. RB: PhD of Reproductive Well being, Division of Midwifery, Nursing and Midwifery College. Bushehr College of Medical Sciences. FH: MS in Nursing, Nursing and Midwifery College. Bushehr College of Medical Sciences. HV: PhD of Nursing, Division of Nursing and Midwifery College. Bushehr College of Medical Sciences, Salmanefarsi Blvd, Bushehr. Iran.
Authors’ contributions S.P.G, H. V, F. Ok and R. B designed the examine, organized ethics approval, S.P.G, H. V, R. B, F. H intervened and information collected. R. B analyzed the info. S.P.G drafted the manuscript and R. B ready tables. All authors learn, edited for scientific accuracy, and authorized the ultimate manuscript.
Funding This analysis was funded by Bushehr College of Medical Sciences.
Availability of knowledge and supplies The anonymized datasets used and/or analyzed throughout the present examine can be found from the corresponding creator on affordable request.
Declarations
Ethics approval and consent to take part This paper is extracted from a grasp’s diploma thesis of the College of Nursing and Midwifery of Bushehr College of Medical Sciences, Bushehr, Iran; which was authorized in 2018 and was Analysis Ethics Committee (Code: 1397.128. IR.BPUMS.REC) and IRCT code)IRCT20090522001930N3) 18/03/2019. A written consent was additional obtained from all of the examine samples.
Competing pursuits The authors report no conflicts of curiosity on this work.
Writer particulars 1 Pupil Analysis Committee, Nursing and Midwifery College, Bushehr Uni- versity of Medical Sciences, Bushehr, Iran. 2 Division of Midwifery, Nursing and Midwifery College, Bushehr College of Medical Sciences, Bushehr, Iran. three Division of Nursing, Nursing and Midwifery College, Bushehr College of Medical Sciences, Salmanefarsi Blvd, Bushehr, Iran.
Obtained: 18 January 2021 Accepted: 27 January 2022
References 1. Mostafazadeh F, Asadzadeh-Monir F, Rostamnejad M, Rhostamneghad
M. Strategies of affected person security schooling for medical group college students. Iran J Obstet Gynecol. 2013;Eight(1):23–9.
2. Ranjbar Ok, Soltani F, Mousavi nassab M, Masoudi A, Ayatollahi SA. Comparability of the affect of conventional and multimedia independ- ent educating strategies on nursing college students` expertise in administrating remedy. Iran J of Med Educ. 2003;9:35–43.
three. Gu M, Sok SR. Results of simulation practicum utilizing flipped learn- ing for Korean nursing college students. Int J Environ Res Public Well being. 2020;17(18):6829. https:// doi. org/ 10. 3390/ ijerp h1718 6829.
Four. Enfield J. Wanting on the affect of the flipped classroom mannequin of instruction on undergraduate multimedia college students at CSUN. Tech- Developments. 2013;57(6):14–27.
5. Harrington SA, Bosch MV, Schoofs N, Beel-Bates C, Anderson Ok. Quanti- tative outcomes for nursing college students in a flipped classroom. Nurs Educ Perspect. 2015;36(three):179–81. https:// doi. org/ 10. 5480/ 13- 1255.
6. Karimi Monaghi H, Rad M, Bakhshi M. Do the brand new strategies of educating in medical schooling have ample efficacy?: a scientific evaluate. Strides Dev of Med Educ. 2013;10(three):153–62.
7. Mikkelsen TR. Nursing college students’ experiences, perceptions and habits in a flipped-classroom anatomy and physiology course. J Nurs Educ Pract. 2015;5(10):28. https:// doi. org/ 10. 5430/ jnep. v5n10 p28.
https://doi.org/10.3390/ijerph17186829
https://doi.org/10.5480/13-1255
https://doi.org/10.5430/jnep.v5n10p28
Web page 11 of 11Golaki et al. BMC Medical Schooling (2022) 22:112
• quick, handy on-line submission
•
thorough peer evaluate by skilled researchers in your discipline
• speedy publication on acceptance
• Help for analysis information, together with giant and complicated information varieties
•
gold Open Entry which fosters wider collaboration and elevated citations
most visibility to your analysis: over 100M web site views per yr •
At BMC, analysis is at all times in progress.
Be taught extra biomedcentral.com/submissions
Able to submit your researchReady to submit your analysis ? Select BMC and profit from: ? Select BMC and profit from:
Eight. Missildine Ok, Fountain R, Summers L, Gosselin Ok. Flipping the class- room to enhance scholar efficiency and satisfaction. J Nurs Educ. 2013;52(10):597–9. https:// doi. org/ 10. 3928/ 01484 834- 20130 919- 03.
9. Overmyer GR. The flipped classroom mannequin for faculty algebra: Results on scholar achievement. PhD Dissertation, Colorado State Univer- sity; 2014. http:// hdl. handel. web/ 10217/ 83800.
10. Salehi S, Safavi M, Mashoof S, Parchebafieh S, Fesharaki M. Results of peer schooling on medical expertise in nursing college students, together with interns and trainees. Med Sci J Islam Azad Univ Tehran Med Department. 2016;26(1):36–45.
11. Adib-Hajbaghery M, Motaharian ES. Educating by near-peer methodology in medical schooling: a scientific evaluate. Iran J Med Educ. 2016;16:366–78.
12. Shohani M, Moradi S, Khorshidi A, Jalilian M. Comparability of the impact of “near-peer” educating and coach readily available hygiene in first yr nursing college students of Ilam College of Medical Sciences. J Adv Pharm Educ Res. 2020;10(1):83.
13. Bahadorani M, Yousefy AR, Changiz T. The effectiveness of three strategies of educating medline to medical college students: on-line, nose to nose and com- bined academic strategies. Iran J Med Educ. 2006;6(2):35–43.
14. Jackson TA, Evans DJ. Can medical college students educate? A near-peer-led teach- ing program for yr 1 college students. Adv Physiol Educ. 2012;36(three):192–6. https:// doi. org/ 10. 1152/ advan. 00Zero35. 2012.
15. Kimyai S, Jafari Navimipour E, Mohammadi N. The impact of peer educa- tion on sensible expertise coaching of dentistry college students in restorative preclinic. Iran J Med Educ. 2011;11(Four):418–24.
16. Norozi HM, Mohsenizadeh SM, Jafary suny H, Ebrahimzadeh S. The impact of educating uning a mix of collaborative and mastery of studying mod- els, on studying of important indicators: an experiment onnursing and operation room college students of Mashhad College of Medical Sciences. Iran J Med Educ. 2011;11(5):544–53.
17. Bagheri M, Joshaghan NF. Impact of flipped studying methodology on college students’ self- directed studying readiness and studying within the laptop fundamentals course. Curr Technol. 2016;1(1):49–61. https:// doi. org/ 10. 22077/ jct. 2016. 662.
18. Li B-Z, Cao N-W, Ren C-X, Chu X-J. Flipped classroom improves nurs- ing college students’ theoretical studying in China: a meta-analysis. Plos One. 2020;15(Eight):e0237926. https:// doi. org/ 10. 1371/ journ al. pone. 02379 26.
19. Egeland I. Data retention in organizations. A literature evaluate and case examine exploring how organizations can switch and retain knowl- edge to mitigate data loss when older staff retire. Grasp Thesis, College of Stavanger Norway; 2017. http:// hdl. handel. web/ 11250/ 24595 74.
20. Sadeghi R, Sedaghat MM, Shaahmadi F. Comparability of the impact of lecture and blended educating strategies on college students’ studying and satis- faction. J Adv Med EducProf. 2014;2(Four):146–50.
21. Mohammad A. Affected person security curriculum. kak khiyal; 2016. 22. WHO. Pointers readily available hygiene in well being care, The burden of well being
caer-associated an infection; 2009. p. 6–7. 23. Thompson DA, Cowan J, Holzmueller C. Planning and implementing a
systems-based affected person security curriculum in medical schooling. Am J Med Qual. 2008;23(Four):271–Eight. https:// doi. org/ 10. 1177/ 10628 60608 317763.
24. Walton M, Woodward H, Van Staalduinen S, Lemer C, Greaves F, Noble D, et al. The WHO affected person security curriculum information for medical faculties. BMJ Qual Saf. 2010;19(6):542–6. https:// doi. org/ 10. 1136/ qshc. 2009. 036970.
25. Ding C, Li S, Chen B. Effectiveness of flipped classroom mixed with team-, case-, lecture-and evidence-based studying on ophthalmology educating for eight-year program college students. BMC Med Educ. 2019;19:419. https:// doi. org/ 10. 1186/ s12909- Zero19- 1861-y.
26. Halasa S, Abusalim N, Rayyan M, Constantino RE, Nassar O, Amre H, et al. Evaluating scholar achievement in conventional studying with a combina- tion of blended and flipped studying. Nurs Open. 2020;7(Four):1129–38. https:// doi. org/ 10. 1002/ nop2. 492.
27. Guraya SY, Abdalla ME. Figuring out the effectiveness of peer-Helped studying in medical schooling: a systemic evaluate and meta-analysis. J Tai- bah Univ Med Sci. 2020;30(15):177–84. https:// doi. org/ 10. 1016/j. tumed. 2020. 05. 002.
28. Kim YM, Yoon YS, Hong HC, Min A. Results of a affected person security course utilizing a flipped classroom strategy amongst undergraduate nursing college students: a quasi-experimental examine. Nurse Educ In the present day. 2019;79:180–7. https:// doi. org/ 10. 1016/j. nedt. 2019. 05. Zero33.
29. Charles-Ogan G, Williams C. Flipped classroom versus a traditional classroom within the studying of arithmetic. Paper introduced on the Proc South Africa Int Convention Educ Technol. 2015;three(6):71–7.
30. Chu T-L, Wang J, Monrouxe L, Sung Y-C. The results of the flipped class- room in educating proof primarily based nursing: a quasi-experimental examine. Plos One. 2019;14(1):e0210606. https:// doi. org/ 10. 1371/ journ al. pone. 02106 06.
31. Hu R, Gao H, Ye Y, Ni Z, Jiang N, Jiang X. Effectiveness of flipped class- rooms in Chinese language baccalaureate nursing schooling: a meta-analysis of randomized managed trials. Int J Nurs Stud. 2018;79:94–103. https:// doi. org/ 10. 1016/j. ijnur stu. 2017. 11. Zero12.
32. Hatami Rad R, Yamani N, Ehsanpour S. Results of teacher-centered teach- ing and peer educating strategies on enhancing some medical expertise of mid- wifery college students: a comparative examine. Iran J Med Educ. 2017;17:335–43.
33. Sevenhuysen S, Skinner EH, Farlie MK, Raitman L, Nickson W, Keating JL, et al. Educators and college students choose conventional medical schooling to a peer-Helped studying mannequin, regardless of comparable scholar efficiency outcomes: a randomised trial. J Phys. 2014;60(Four):209–16. https:// doi. org/ 10. 1016/j. jphys. 2014. 09. 004.
34. Deubel P. An investigation of behaviorist and cognitive approaches to tutorial multimedia design. J Educ Multimed Hypermed. 2003;12(1):63–90.
35. Whillier S, Lystad RP. No variations in grades or stage of satisfaction in a flipped classroom for neuroanatomy. J Chiropr Educ. 2015;29(2):127–33. https:// doi. org/ 10. 7899/ jce- 14- 28.
36. Haghani F, Rezaei H, Baeigzade A, Eghbali B. Flipped classroom: a peda- gogical methodology. Iran J Med Educ. 2016;16(11):104–19.
37. Liu WI, Edwards H, Courtney M. Assessment of constant skilled educa- tion in case administration for nurses. Nurse Educ In the present day. 2009;29(5):488– 92. https:// doi. org/ 10. 1016/j. nedt. 2008. 11. 004.
38. Graham KL, Cohen A, Reynolds EE, Huang GC. Impact of a flipped class- room on data acquisition and retention in an inside medication residency program. J Grad Med Educ. 2019;11(1):92–7. https:// doi. org/ 10. 4300/ jgme-d- 18- 00536.1.
39. Javaheri Arasteh A, Najafi Ghezeljeh T, Haghani S. Results of peer-Helped schooling on the data and efficiency of nursing college students in fundamental cardiopulmonary resuscitation. Iran J Nurs. 2018;31(115):6–19. https:// doi. org/ 10. 29252/ ijn. 31. 115.6.
40. Abdulghani HM, Al-Drees AA, Khalil MS, Ahmad F, Ponnamperuma G, Amin Z. What elements decide educational achievement in excessive achiev- ing undergraduate medical college students? A qualitative examine. Med Educate. 2014;36:43–Eight. https:// doi. org/ 10. 3109/ 01421 59X. 2014. 886011.
Writer’s Notice Springer Nature stays impartial with regard to jurisdictional claims in pub- lished maps and institutional affiliations.
https://doi.org/10.3928/01484834-20130919-03
http://www.hdl.handel.web/10217/83800
https://doi.org/10.1152/advan.00Zero35.2012
https://doi.org/10.22077/jct.2016.662
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0237926
http://www.hdl.handel.web/11250/2459574
http://www.hdl.handel.web/11250/2459574
https://doi.org/10.1177/1062860608317763
https://doi.org/10.1136/qshc.2009.036970
https://doi.org/10.1186/s12909-Zero19-1861-y
https://doi.org/10.1002/nop2.492
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tumed.2020.05.002
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tumed.2020.05.002
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.nedt.2019.05.Zero33
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.nedt.2019.05.Zero33
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0210606
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0210606
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijnurstu.2017.11.Zero12
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijnurstu.2017.11.Zero12
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jphys.2014.09.004
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jphys.2014.09.004
https://doi.org/10.7899/jce-14-28
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.nedt.2008.11.004
https://doi.org/10.4300/jgme-d-18-00536.1
https://doi.org/10.4300/jgme-d-18-00536.1
https://doi.org/10.29252/ijn.31.115.6
https://doi.org/10.3109/0142159X.2014.886011
The impact of Flipped Classroom by Close to Peer Schooling (FC by NPE) on affected person security data retention in nursing and midwifery college students: a solomon four-group design
Summary
Introduction:
Strategies:
Outcomes:
Conclusion:
Background
Strategies
Research design
Topics
Typical methodology
FC by NPE methodology
Intervention
Knowledge analysis
Statements
Knowledge Assessment
Outcomes
Dialogue
Conclusion
Acknowledgements
References
